Warzone Player Count Decline: Why Are Gamers Leaving?

Understand the reasons behind the Warzone player count decline and explore the frustrations players face with technical issues and game design choices.

Photo of author

Samantha

Warzone in Disarray: Why Players Are Frustrated

Warzone’s in a tough spot. The player count is dropping, and frankly, it’s understandable. Between frustrating bugs, questionable design choices, and a never-ending stream of premium bundles, many players are simply moving on. Whether you’re a die-hard fan or just dipping your toes in, this Warzone player count decline affects us all. Let’s explore why Warzone is losing players, what it means for the future of the game, and what Activision can do to bring players back.

Key Takeaways

  • Warzone faces interconnected challenges: Technical difficulties, cheating, and perceived developer missteps combine to create a frustrating experience for players, impacting both casual enjoyment and competitive integrity.
  • Competitive players feel the impact most acutely: The combination of in-game issues and a lack of effective solutions undermines the competitive scene, affecting both ranked play and the professional CDL.
  • Addressing player concerns is key for Warzone’s future: Open communication, prioritizing bug fixes, and focusing on player satisfaction are crucial for rebuilding trust and retaining the player base.

Is Warzone in Trouble?

Is Warzone Stable?

Warzone players have been grappling with frustrating stability and performance problems. From game crashes and lag to a plethora of glitches, these issues significantly impact the overall gameplay experience. It’s especially disheartening for those in Warzone Ranked Play, where a smooth, consistent experience is crucial for competitive integrity. While Activision Support encourages players to submit crash reports to help identify and resolve these issues, the lack of official acknowledgment from Call of Duty about the extent of these problems leaves many players feeling ignored. This silence, combined with persistent technical difficulties, breeds frustration and distrust within the community.

Warzone Player Count vs. Warzone 2.0 Launch

The launch of Warzone 2.0 in late 2022 had a noticeable impact on the original Warzone’s player count. Dexerto reported that Warzone lost over 102,000 players on Steam alone—a significant 32.6% of its player base at the time. This drop mirrors the trend seen after Warzone 2.0’s release, suggesting players may have migrated to the newer title. This trend is worth watching, especially as Warzone continues to face challenges.

Lowest Recorded Player Count on Steam

Warzone hit its lowest recorded player count on Steam in July 2023, with only 86,000 players. This data from Dexerto highlights the difficulties the game faces in retaining its player base. While player counts can fluctuate, this low point underscores the seriousness of the situation and raises questions about the game’s future.

Recent Peak Player Counts

Despite these challenges, Warzone isn’t out of the game yet. Recent peak player counts on Steam reached 212,000, showing a dedicated community still plays. However, the overall downward trend, combined with the reported lows, raises concerns about its long-term health. Whether these peaks are temporary or represent sustained engagement remains to be seen. It’s a critical time for Warzone, and Activision’s response will likely determine its future.

Are Cheaters Ruining Warzone?

Adding to the instability issues, Warzone continues to struggle with a pervasive cheating problem. The presence of cheaters undermines the competitive integrity of the game, discouraging fair players and creating an uneven playing field. This issue, coupled with the ongoing technical difficulties and the rise of other competitive shooters, contributes to the dwindling player base in Call of Duty. Each integration with the latest Call of Duty multiplayer title often introduces a fresh wave of changes, sometimes exacerbating existing problems and making the game feel worse, as some players have claimed. This cycle of updates and recurring issues further fuels player frustration and raises concerns about the game’s future.

Why Are Warzone Players Frustrated?

Warzone has always had its ups and downs, but lately, player frustration seems to be at an all-time high. It’s not just one thing; it’s a combination of issues impacting both casual and competitive players, creating a perfect storm of discontent.

The State of Competitive Play

For competitive players, Warzone Ranked Play is where the problems hit hardest. The issues, ranging from glitches to server instability, are amplified in a competitive setting where every second and every decision matters. One report highlights how these problems make the competitive experience miserable, especially when combined with the game’s price tag and the constant promotion of premium bundles. The lack of official acknowledgment from the developers only adds fuel to the fire.

Are Casual Players Forgotten?

Casual players aren’t immune to the frustration either. Many feel outright abandoned, dealing with the same bugs and performance issues that plague competitive play. This neglect of the core game experience affects everyone, not just those focused on ranked modes. One popular streamer voiced this frustration, expressing the sentiment that the developers don’t care about the casual player base.

Movement Mechanics and Controller Limitations

Modern Call of Duty titles, including Warzone, have introduced complex movement mechanics like slide-canceling and omni-directional movement. While these mechanics add depth for some, they create a barrier to entry for others. Many players, especially those using controllers, find these techniques challenging to master. The speed and precision required can be difficult for casual players or those with less dexterity. This creates an uneven playing field, especially noticeable in fast-paced Warzone matches. As discussed on Reddit, these advanced movements contribute to the game’s difficulty, pushing away newer and casual players.

The Skill Ceiling Debate

The combination of complex movement and skill-based matchmaking (SBMM) creates a steep learning curve in Warzone. New players are often matched against experienced players who have mastered these advanced techniques. This can lead to frustrating matches where new players struggle to learn the basics. This “trial by fire” approach can discourage new players and contribute to a sense of imbalance. This same Reddit thread highlights how this combination creates a difficult environment for newcomers, hindering their enjoyment and progress.

Warzone: Potential vs. Reality

Perhaps the most disheartening aspect of Warzone’s current state is the disconnect between its potential and its reality. Many players agree that the core gameplay has a strong foundation. However, technical issues, questionable design choices, and a perceived lack of developer support hold the game back. This “lost potential,” as discussed by OpTic ZLaner, resonates with many in the community. Players see a game they love struggling, and the yearly Call of Duty release cycle creates a sense that any progress made is eventually reset.

Developer Decisions: What’s Going On?

It’s no secret that Warzone has been facing some serious challenges. But some of the decisions made by the developers have left players scratching their heads, wondering what’s going on behind the scenes.

Why These Decisions?

One of the biggest frustrations stems from seemingly random updates that introduce new problems without addressing existing ones. A recent Warzone update reportedly caused significant issues, especially in Ranked Play. The lack of official acknowledgment from Call of Duty only adds fuel to the fire, leaving players feeling ignored. This isn’t just about bugs; it’s about the lack of communication and transparency, which erodes trust between the developers and the community.

Early Release Theory and Broken Trust

One theory circulating among players is that Warzone was released prematurely. While this is speculative, the sheer number of bugs and performance issues since launch lends some credence to this idea. This perceived early release, coupled with repeated unmet promises regarding fixes for cheating and other problems (like the ineffective Ricochet anti-cheat system), has fractured the trust between players and the developers. As one analysis suggests, prominent streamers report encountering multiple hackers per match—a staggering statistic that underscores the severity of the issue. This constant battle against cheaters, combined with the feeling of playing an unfinished game, creates disillusionment within the community. It feels like a betrayal of the initial excitement and promise surrounding Warzone’s debut.

Engagement-Optimized Matchmaking Suspicions

Beyond the technical issues and cheating problems, there’s a growing suspicion among players that the matchmaking system isn’t entirely fair. Some believe that skill-based matchmaking (SBMM) is used not just to create balanced matches, but also to manipulate player engagement. The theory posits that the system intentionally places players in matches where they’re more likely to experience both wins and losses, keeping them hooked. This can lead to frustratingly inconsistent gameplay, where one match feels easy and the next impossibly difficult. This perceived manipulation, combined with the slow weapon leveling and complex XP mechanics, further fuels player frustration. It creates a sense that the game is designed to maximize playtime, not provide a consistently enjoyable and rewarding experience. Even in-game events, often a source of excitement in other titles, are frequently seen as unengaging and boring, adding another layer to the overall dissatisfaction.

Is the Community Being Heard?

While developers claim to be “gathering community feedback,” the actual impact of this feedback seems minimal. Players have been vocal about issues like crossplay cheating in ranked Warzone, yet meaningful solutions remain elusive. The yearly integration with the latest Call of Duty title often brings a boatload of changes, but not always for the better. Many feel these changes disrupt the established meta and create new imbalances.

Disconnect Between Developers and Players

The frustration simmering within the Warzone community isn’t just about bugs or cheaters; it’s about a perceived disconnect between the developers and the players. This sentiment, echoed across forums and social media, highlights a growing gap in understanding and communication. It’s a feeling that many gamers, especially those invested in live-service titles, know all too well.

One of the most common complaints? The lack of acknowledgment from Activision regarding the severity of Warzone’s problems. As this Z League article points out, this silence creates a sense of being ignored, fostering distrust and resentment. Players want solutions, of course, but they also want to feel heard and understood. It’s about more than just fixing bugs; it’s about acknowledging the impact those bugs have on the community.

This feeling of disconnect is amplified by what many perceive as a lack of transparency in decision-making. Updates often introduce new issues without addressing existing ones, leaving players confused and frustrated. Reports on a recent problematic Warzone update highlight this issue, emphasizing how a lack of communication erodes trust. It creates a sense that decisions are being made without considering the actual player experience.

Even when developers claim to be “gathering community feedback,” the impact of this feedback often feels minimal. Players have long been vocal about issues like crossplay cheating, as discussed in this Dot Esports piece, yet meaningful solutions remain elusive. This perceived lack of action reinforces the feeling that developers are out of touch with the community’s needs. It’s like shouting into a void, and that can be incredibly disheartening for dedicated players.

Ultimately, this disconnect creates disillusionment. Players see the potential of Warzone, a game they genuinely enjoy, hampered by technical issues and questionable decisions. Coupled with the feeling of not being heard, it contributes to the growing frustration. Head over to Z League for more community-focused gaming discussions, like reactions to Diablo 4 and Honkai: Star Rail. It’s a good reminder of how much player interaction and feedback matters in the gaming world.

Premium Bundles: Worth It?

The constant influx of premium bundles in a full-priced game is a contentious issue. While microtransactions are a common practice, the sheer volume and sometimes questionable value of these bundles in Warzone have drawn criticism. This, combined with the frustrating state of competitive play, contributes to a sense that the focus is shifting away from gameplay and towards monetization. Players are left wondering if the developers are prioritizing profits over providing a polished and enjoyable experience.

Microtransaction Pricing Concerns

The sheer number of premium bundles available in Warzone is overwhelming, and their pricing often feels exorbitant. Players are already invested in a full-priced game; the constant barrage of new bundles with high price tags can feel predatory, especially when the value proposition of those bundles is sometimes questionable. Are these cosmetics truly worth the cost, or are they just another way to squeeze more money out of a dedicated player base? This concern is amplified when considering the current state of the game, with persistent bugs and performance issues. It creates a sense that Activision is prioritizing monetization over addressing the core problems impacting gameplay, as one report highlights. This sentiment resonates with many players who feel nickel-and-dimed despite having already paid for the game.

Warzone’s Impact on Competitive Gaming

Competitive Call of Duty has always been a rollercoaster. Highs, lows, and everything in between. But lately, it feels like the ride is stuck in a downward spiral, and players are getting frustrated. This frustration stems from several key issues impacting both the professional Call of Duty League (CDL) and the everyday ranked play experience in Warzone.

Challenges Facing the CDL

Popular Warzone streamer ZLANER recently voiced concerns echoing what many in the community feel: the CDL’s management seems disconnected from its player base. Decisions often appear random and backward, leaving fans scratching their heads. ZLANER points out that the CDL faces a “boatload of problems,” and these issues trickle down, impacting the overall perception of competitive Call of Duty. When the professional scene struggles, it can dampen enthusiasm for the game as a whole.

Is Ranked Play Fair?

Beyond the CDL, the ranked play experience in Warzone has also drawn considerable criticism. Reports of persistent issues, including game-breaking bugs, have left players feeling ignored and frustrated with the lack of communication from developers. The competitive integrity of Warzone’s ranked mode is crucial for player investment. When these systems are flawed, it undermines the competitive spirit and discourages players from taking ranked play seriously. One article highlights this frustration, describing the ranked experience as “miserable” and pointing to a disconnect between the game’s monetization and the actual quality of competitive play. This combination of technical problems and perceived developer indifference creates a breeding ground for negativity within the community.

Why is Warzone’s Player Count Dropping?

Understanding Warzone’s Steam Numbers

Recent statistics paint a grim picture of Warzone’s player engagement. The game saw a drop of over 102,000 players on Steam, a whopping 32.6% decrease in just 30 days as of December 19, 2023. This sharp decline points to a larger trend of player dissatisfaction. You can read more about the Warzone player count drop at Dexerto.

Comparing Black Ops 6 and Modern Warfare 3 Decline

The dwindling player base isn’t unique to Warzone. Black Ops 6 has seen a dramatic drop in players on Steam, reaching numbers reminiscent of late Modern Warfare 3 levels. This decline is especially alarming considering it happened within just two months of Black Ops 6’s October 2024 release, as reported by TheGamer. To put this in perspective, Black Ops 6 lost 79% of its peak players in two months, compared to Modern Warfare 3’s 67% drop over almost a year. This rapid decline raises serious questions about player retention and the long-term health of the Call of Duty franchise.

Disputed Player Count Decrease Claims on Reddit

Concern over declining player counts extends beyond official statistics and into community discussions. A Reddit post claiming an 83% drop in Warzone’s player base since December sparked a heated debate. While the original poster’s calculation was disputed, the overall sentiment remains: players perceive a significant decrease in the active player base. Comments highlight recurring issues like cheating, unbalanced matchmaking, and a perceived lack of developer responsiveness. Even without precise numbers, the community’s shared experience points to a problem Activision can’t ignore.

Why Are Players Leaving Warzone?

Several factors contribute to this exodus. Call of Duty boasted 150 million monthly active users in early 2021, but that number plummeted to 98 million by March 2023. Technical problems with both Modern Warfare 2 and Warzone 2 are major culprits. Beyond technical issues, players are frustrated with the lack of content updates for Warzone, ongoing server problems, and a persistent cheating problem. The rise of competing shooters, like XDefiant, is also drawing players away. Activision has lost millions of players in 2023. The overall picture is stark: Call of Duty has lost roughly 50 million players in a single year, according to PC Gamer, signaling the need for Activision to take decisive action.

Infographic addressing player concerns about Warzone and potential solutions.

Unpopular Map: Area 99

The new Resurgence map, Area 99, hasn’t been a hit with players. Many find it uninspired and lacking the dynamic gameplay of previous maps. This disappointment contributes to the overall sense of stagnation in Warzone, especially with the missing large-map experience.

The Verdansk Void: Missing a Large Map

The removal of Verdansk left a void that hasn’t been filled. Players miss the large-scale engagements and strategic depth of a sprawling map. This absence, coupled with the lukewarm reception of Area 99, leaves players wanting more substantial content and variety. Dexerto reported on this player sentiment, highlighting the desire for a return to large-scale maps.

Slow Weapon Leveling and Complex XP

Leveling up weapons in Warzone feels excessively slow and convoluted. The complex XP mechanics add another layer of frustration, making unlocking attachments and progressing feel like a chore. This tedious process discourages experimentation and makes the game feel less rewarding, especially for casual players. This sentiment was echoed in a recent video discussing Warzone’s current state.

AI Voice and Art Controversy

Using AI-generated voices and art in Warzone has sparked controversy among players and voice actors. Many feel this approach devalues human artists’ creative contributions and raises ethical concerns. This controversy, while seemingly separate from gameplay issues, adds to the growing negativity surrounding Warzone’s development. The same video discussing weapon leveling also touched on the AI controversy and its impact.

Integration Fatigue and Yearly Releases

The annual Call of Duty release cycle, while financially successful for Activision, creates integration fatigue for Warzone players. Each new game brings changes to weapons, mechanics, and progression, forcing players to relearn and regrind content year after year. This constant reset can be demoralizing, especially for long-time players. This issue of yearly resets was also highlighted in the video discussing player frustrations.

Lack of Marketing Hype

The subdued marketing around recent Warzone updates speaks volumes. The lack of fanfare suggests a lack of confidence in the product, further fueling player concerns. This quiet approach contrasts sharply with previous updates and raises questions about Activision’s commitment to Warzone’s future. The same video discussing Warzone also pointed to the lack of marketing as a potential red flag.

Unengaging In-Game Events

Warzone’s in-game events have failed to capture player interest. Many feel recent events have been lackluster, offering little engaging gameplay or rewarding experiences. This lack of compelling content contributes to the feeling of stagnation and pushes players towards other games with more dynamic events. The Gamer discussed this decline in player engagement, linking it to a lack of compelling content.

The Competitive Landscape: Other Popular Games

While Warzone struggles, other competitive shooters are thriving. Titles like Fortnite and Marvel Rivals have seen player growth, drawing attention away from Warzone. This competitive landscape highlights the importance of addressing player concerns and providing a compelling experience. Dexerto’s report on Warzone’s player count drop also mentioned the rise of competing games.

Balancing Casual and Competitive in Warzone

One of the biggest challenges facing Warzone is finding a sweet spot between catering to casual players and nurturing a healthy competitive scene. It’s a tightrope walk, and right now, many players feel like the game is teetering on the edge.

Meeting Player Needs in Warzone

Warzone has always attracted a diverse player base, from those who enjoy a few casual matches after work to dedicated competitors grinding for leaderboard dominance. The problem? Both groups feel neglected. Casual players are often overwhelmed by the skill gap, finding themselves consistently outmatched. Meanwhile, competitive players grapple with issues like frustrating bugs and glitches that impact ranked play. This combination of a less-than-ideal competitive experience and the constant push for premium bundles creates a sense of frustration that bleeds into the overall enjoyment of the game, as one writer notes. It’s a sentiment echoed by many in the community, who feel like the game is becoming less fun regardless of their play style. This dissatisfaction is further fueled by the yearly integration with the latest Call of Duty multiplayer, which often brings sweeping changes that disrupt the established meta and leave players feeling like the game is constantly in flux, as discussed in this article.

Community Recommendations: Boycotts and In-Game Purchases

Player frustration has reached a boiling point, and the community is actively discussing ways to make their voices heard. One trending suggestion involves boycotting the next battle pass. This tactic aims to hit Activision’s bottom line and demonstrate the player base’s collective power. Another recommendation circulating within the community focuses on in-game purchases. Players suggest a coordinated effort to stop buying cosmetic items, sending a clear message that the current monetization strategies are unacceptable. These discussions highlight the growing dissatisfaction with the game’s direction and the community’s willingness to take action.

Hardcore Mode: A Community Suggestion

Amidst the frustration, some players offer constructive suggestions to improve the gameplay experience. One recurring idea gaining traction is the reintroduction of a Hardcore mode. This mode, a staple in previous Call of Duty titles, offers a more stripped-down, skill-based experience. By removing some of the more controversial movement mechanics and emphasizing gunplay, Hardcore mode could provide a refreshing alternative for players seeking a more balanced and competitive environment. This suggestion reflects a desire within the community for a return to the franchise’s roots and a focus on core gameplay mechanics. It’s a potential solution that could appease both casual and competitive players looking for a more grounded experience.

How to Improve the Warzone Experience

So, how can Warzone address these concerns and create a more balanced experience? First, acknowledging the issues is crucial. The lack of official communication regarding the problems plaguing ranked play, as highlighted by Gamerant, only exacerbates the frustration within the competitive community. Openly addressing these concerns and outlining a plan for improvement would go a long way in rebuilding trust. Second, prioritizing fixes for bugs and glitches that disproportionately affect competitive play is essential. This demonstrates a commitment to both casual and competitive players, showing that their experiences are valued. Finally, fostering a more open dialogue with the community, including prominent figures like OpTic ZLaner, who has voiced concerns, can provide valuable insights. By actively listening to feedback and implementing changes based on community input, Warzone can create a more inclusive and enjoyable experience for everyone.

Warzone’s Technical Hurdles

Warzone’s technical problems add another layer of frustration for players. From persistent bugs and glitches to problematic updates, these challenges significantly impact the overall gameplay experience.

Bugs and Glitches in Warzone

Players frequently encounter various in-game bugs and glitches. These range from minor annoyances to game-breaking issues that disrupt matches, sometimes leading to unfair eliminations. The lack of official acknowledgment from Activision for some problems, particularly in Ranked Play, further fuels player frustration. While Activision encourages players to submit crash reports to help identify and resolve these issues, the persistent bugs suggest a deeper problem. For a competitive game like Warzone, glitches can compromise the integrity of matches, especially in ranked modes where players invest significant time and effort. One report highlights how the combination of technical issues and the constant promotion of premium bundles creates a less-than-ideal experience.

Warzone Update Issues

Integrating Warzone with the latest Call of Duty multiplayer title each year brings its own set of challenges. While shared progression is a welcome feature, the sheer volume of changes introduced with each new update often leads to new bugs, glitches, and sometimes performance issues. This constant cycle of updates and resulting problems contributes to the feeling that Warzone is in constant flux, never quite reaching a stable and polished state. This instability, along with other issues like cheating and competition from other rising shooters, contributes to player frustration and declining player numbers.

The Future of Warzone and Call of Duty

Warzone’s popularity has taken a hit. Once boasting 150 million monthly active users, the game saw that number drop to 98 million by March 2023. Technical issues in both Modern Warfare 2 and Warzone 2, alongside the rise of competitive shooters like XDefiant, contributed to this player decline. This raises questions about the future of the franchise and what steps Activision might take to recapture its audience.

Will the Release Cycle Change?

The annual release cycle of Call of Duty games has been a long-standing tradition. However, some argue this rapid-fire approach may be detrimental to the franchise’s overall health. With less time to polish each game and address technical problems, players are often left with buggy and unstable experiences. A shift towards a longer development cycle could lead to more refined and complete games, ultimately benefiting both players and the franchise’s longevity. This would also give developers more time to address community concerns and implement meaningful changes.

Community-Driven Solutions for Warzone

While Activision works on addressing Warzone’s technical issues, the community has offered potential solutions. One major concern is the rampant cheating problem, particularly in Ranked Play. Players have expressed frustration with the lack of effective anti-cheat measures and the impact on competitive integrity. Community feedback suggests stricter anti-cheat implementation, increased communication from developers, and more active moderation of ranked playlists. Addressing these issues is crucial for retaining players and fostering a healthy competitive environment. Additionally, players have raised concerns about the prevalence of premium bundles in a full-priced game, especially when combined with a subpar competitive experience. Finding a better balance between monetization and player satisfaction will be key to Warzone’s future success.

Can Warzone Be Saved?

Warzone has faced its share of struggles. Can it bounce back? The short answer is: it’s complicated. The long answer involves acknowledging the issues and charting a course correction.

Areas for Improvement in Warzone

Right now, several key areas need attention. The problems plaguing Warzone Ranked Play are particularly concerning, impacting the competitive integrity of the game. It’s frustrating for players when core features aren’t functioning correctly, especially without official acknowledgment from the developers. Beyond ranked play, the overall player experience has suffered. The constant push of premium bundles in a full-priced game adds insult to injury when the competitive experience feels lacking. This isn’t just about winning or losing; it’s about having fun, and many players feel that aspect is missing. The integration with each new Call of Duty title often brings a fresh wave of issues, leaving players feeling like the game is constantly two steps forward, one step back.

Warzone’s Long-Term Prospects

The decline in player engagement is a serious issue. Reports indicate a significant drop in active players, and the rise of competing shooters like XDefiant adds to the challenge. The combination of technical issues and persistent cheaters has created a perfect storm, driving players away. Server problems further impact the enjoyment of the game. While Warzone still has a dedicated player base, its long-term health depends on addressing these fundamental problems and rebuilding player trust.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Warzone really dying?

The significant drop in players on platforms like Steam definitely raises concerns. Coupled with the rise of competing games and ongoing issues within Warzone itself, it’s a worrying trend. Whether this signals the game’s demise or just a temporary dip remains to be seen, but it’s clear Activision needs to take action.

What are the biggest complaints about Warzone right now?

Players are frustrated with a combination of factors. Technical problems, like bugs, glitches, and server instability, top the list. The cheating problem, especially in ranked modes, is another major source of discontent. Many also feel that the focus on premium bundles overshadows the need for core game improvements.

Why are Warzone’s technical issues so persistent?

The yearly integration with the newest Call of Duty title introduces a large number of changes, often leading to new bugs and glitches. This constant cycle of updates and fixes makes it difficult to achieve long-term stability. Also, some players believe that a lack of focus on fixing existing problems before adding new content contributes to the ongoing technical challenges.

What can Activision do to improve Warzone?

Open communication and transparency are key. Acknowledging the issues and outlining a clear plan for improvement would build trust with the community. Prioritizing bug fixes and performance enhancements over new content would also show a commitment to improving the core gameplay experience. Actively listening to and incorporating community feedback is crucial for making meaningful changes.

Is there hope for Warzone’s competitive scene?

The competitive scene’s future depends on addressing the issues that plague ranked play. Fixing bugs, implementing stricter anti-cheat measures, and fostering a more balanced experience for both casual and competitive players are essential steps. The community’s passion for competitive Warzone is still there, but it needs to be nurtured and supported by the developers.